Private Eye Stories That Get It Right
Posted by Writing PIs on March 28, 2012
Today we’re looking at a few writers who nail private investigations in their stories.
Another hour passed. The sun tried to come out for a few seconds, but the clouds reassembled and then it was a normal Michigan sky again. Cars went by, one by one, kicking up slush. I stayed where I was, feeling like I was slipping into some sort of trance, but always with one eye on the side-view mirror.
George Pelecanos, The Cut. Sometimes we think that if we say we’re private investigators, the person will refuse to talk to us, so we’ll simply say we’re investigators or legal investigators…omitting the word “private” can keep the conversation warm. However, we’re careful not to lie about our work, and if asked who we’re working for, we’re upfront that we’re working on behalf of the defense.
In the below dialogue, the PI, Lucas, is looking for potential interviews on a case. Lucas speaks first.
“Look, I don’t mean to bother you, but I’m looking into a theft on this block.”
“I’m an investigator,” said Lucas. It didn’t answer the question exactly, and it wasn’t a lie.
Don Winslow, The Gentlemen’s Hour. Winslow is a former private investigator , so no surprise he nails the PI profession in his writing. The below excerpt, where the PI brainstorms case strategy, legal aspects and the legal players with the attorney, hit home with us. Often we work closely with defense attorneys on case/investigative strategies and issues — this type of “brainstorming” relationship is due to our backgrounds (before returning to the practice of law, one of us was a former criminal defense attorney) and also our established attorney-PI relationships that have been built over time where both sides have proven track records and mutual respect.
In this passage, the attorney-client, Petra, is speaking to the PI, Boone. Corey is the defendant whose family has retained Petra. The first line is Petra’s.
“I’m not sure it’s a viable defense anyway,” she says. “But it’s worth looking into. Where else do you want to take it?”
Boone starts off with where he can’t take it. He can’t talk to Trevor Bodin or the Knowles brothers because their lawyers know that their interests conflict with Corey’s and won’t let the interviews happen. Those kids, smarter than Corey, started making their deals right in the police interview rooms. The best they can hope for is that Alan takes a chunk or two off the rest of the crew’s credibility during cross-exam, but that’s about it. So that’s no good. But he can run down more info on the Rockpile Crew and the “gang” issue, find out what they were all about.
Boone sums all that up for Petra, and then says, “If Corey takes that attitude into a trial, Mary Lou will ride it to a max sentence.”
Have a great week, Writing PIs
- Answering Writer’s Question: Are PIs and Cops Compatible? (writingpis.wordpress.com)
- Private Investigators and Murder Cases (writingpis.wordpress.com)
- Answering Writers’ Questions About Private Investigators Investigating Kidnappings (writingpis.wordpress.com)
- Answering Writers’ Questions: What Records Can PIs Legally Obtain? (writingpis.wordpress.com)
- Excerpt from How Do Private Eyes Do That?: How PIs Are Used in Cases Where DNA Evidence Is Employed (writingpis.wordpress.com)
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.